In today's Gospel, I noticed a line said by Jesus that I have never noticed before. The narrative from Mark 9 goes like this:
As the day was drawing to a close,
the Twelve approached him and said,
"Dismiss the crowd
so that they can go to the surrounding villages and farms
and find lodging and provisions;
for we are in a deserted place here."
He said to them, "Give them some food yourselves."
It seems the disciples think they are doing the right thing in altering their leader of the needs and concerns of people. They were very much playing the 'advisor' role to their leader. They were probably expecting Jesus to say something like, "Yeah thanks. You are right. Let's get them out of here for their own benefit". Instead, Jesus says, "Give them some food yourselves". It was a challenge, perhaps foreshadowing what would happen after Easter. For after Easter, the disciples, through the resurrection, needed to be ones doing the feeding.
So while the Gospel passage focuses on the miracle, it is a good reminder for me that I sometimes need to take action instead of 'advising' others.
Just as Jesus taught in the Temple Courtyard in Jerusalem, this blog hopes to be a conversation about Scripture with goal of understanding and knowing Jesus in a greater way. Everyone's thoughts are welcomed, needed and appreciated. Please leave a comment and follow the blog by subscribing below. Thanks for participating.
Sunday, May 29, 2016
Sunday, May 8, 2016
Stephen and Paul
Common to Biblical study is something called the 'Criteria of Embarrassment'. This means that when something is included in the scripture that is embarissing, it is probably historically accurate. For instance, when Peter denies Jesus 3 times, nobody is writing that in or making it up because it is potentially embarrassing to Jesus.
Today is another one of those situations that says a lot about what the scripture writers want us to know. We see Stephan being stoned and the Luke identifies Saul, (who we later takes the name of Paul and become an apostle) to be there as an agitator/persecutor.
Now, Paul's letters, which make up half of the New Testament, were written about the year 50. Luke wrote his Gospel and Acts of the Apostles in the 80's or 90's. So, Luke would have been aware of all the good work that Paul would do after his conversion and could have easily kept Paul's witness to Stephan's death out of Act. But Luke includes it. Why?
I think Luke kept Paul at the scene because this is what Christianity is! None of us live perfect lives. Some worse than others. Saul's was pretty bad at first. But with the saving power of God, through Jesus, it gets turned around. Luke is saying to all of us, "If God can do good with with Saul, imagine what He can do with the rest of us!"
Kind of neat, right?
Today is another one of those situations that says a lot about what the scripture writers want us to know. We see Stephan being stoned and the Luke identifies Saul, (who we later takes the name of Paul and become an apostle) to be there as an agitator/persecutor.
Now, Paul's letters, which make up half of the New Testament, were written about the year 50. Luke wrote his Gospel and Acts of the Apostles in the 80's or 90's. So, Luke would have been aware of all the good work that Paul would do after his conversion and could have easily kept Paul's witness to Stephan's death out of Act. But Luke includes it. Why?
I think Luke kept Paul at the scene because this is what Christianity is! None of us live perfect lives. Some worse than others. Saul's was pretty bad at first. But with the saving power of God, through Jesus, it gets turned around. Luke is saying to all of us, "If God can do good with with Saul, imagine what He can do with the rest of us!"
Kind of neat, right?
Labels:
Acts of the Apostles,
Luke,
Paul,
Saul
Location:
West Sayville, NY, USA
Saturday, May 7, 2016
Being Kind and Gentle
In today's 1st reading from Acts, there is an interesting story of Apollos, who was new to 'The Way'. ('The Way' was the one of the 1st names for what we now call Christianity). Apollos is preaching and he is getting some things wrong. At this point, he is taken aside and Luke writes this:
He began to speak boldly in the synagogue; when Priscilla and Aquila heard him, they took him aside and explained to him the Way of God more accurately. (Act 18:23-28).
Luke does not tell us that Priscilla and Aquila reprimanded or scolded or chastised Apollos. They did not embarrass or ridicule him. They explained. They clarified. They recognized the dignity of someone who had great enthusiasm and was trying to do the right thing.
It is a great reminder of how we are called to treat one another. We probably all know of times where someone's spirit was crushed because they were not treated with kindness and gentleness. It is not by accident that Luke chose to include this in Acts as it can be a reminder to all of us how to act.
He began to speak boldly in the synagogue; when Priscilla and Aquila heard him, they took him aside and explained to him the Way of God more accurately. (Act 18:23-28).
Luke does not tell us that Priscilla and Aquila reprimanded or scolded or chastised Apollos. They did not embarrass or ridicule him. They explained. They clarified. They recognized the dignity of someone who had great enthusiasm and was trying to do the right thing.
It is a great reminder of how we are called to treat one another. We probably all know of times where someone's spirit was crushed because they were not treated with kindness and gentleness. It is not by accident that Luke chose to include this in Acts as it can be a reminder to all of us how to act.
Location:
West Sayville, NY, USA
Wednesday, May 4, 2016
Its On Us and In Us
Bit of a change today. The reflection on Ascension Thursday is in the form of a short video my friend Fr. Rob Ketcham made of me and you can find it at https://petersboat.net/2016/05/04/the-ascension/
Fr. Rob has some amazing videos that are a great help in asking the right questions and finding faith. Please take a look at some of them at www.petersboat.net.
Fr. Rob has some amazing videos that are a great help in asking the right questions and finding faith. Please take a look at some of them at www.petersboat.net.
Labels:
Ascension,
Fr. Rob Ketcham
Location:
West Islip, NY, USA
Monday, May 2, 2016
Woodstock 1999
The last line of the 1st reading today from Paul's 1st Letter of the Corinthians is interesting; "as to one born abnormally, He appeared to me". Paul was probably referencing the fact that he was not a believer in Christ at first. In fact as we know, he persecuted Christians. I think 'abnormal' here means a sinner.
This reminded me of a work experience I had in 1999 in Rome NY. It was billed as Woodstock 99, a rock and roll festival taking its name from the fabled Woodstock festival of 1969. It was everything you might imagine. Lots of music, lots of alcohol and lots of drugs. It was about 4:00 am one morning while I was riding around supplying food stands that I came across a Christian commune. They stood out not only because of the modesty of their cloths, but their singing and dancing. (They were also selling awesome coffee).
I spoke to them for a while and they told me they travelled from rock festival to rock festival and they tried to spread the message about Jesus. I asked them why they were doing that. From what I had seen over the past few days, Jesus was nowhere to be seen. One man from the group replied, "Yes, that is exactly why we are here".
I think perhaps Paul might have been beating himself up a bit by calling himself 'abnormal'. He was a sinner. The people in Woodstock were sinners. When Pope Francis was asked to describe himself, he replied, "I am a sinner". In the sense that Paul means it, I wonder if we are all 'abnormal'? And Christ can appear to all of us too!
This reminded me of a work experience I had in 1999 in Rome NY. It was billed as Woodstock 99, a rock and roll festival taking its name from the fabled Woodstock festival of 1969. It was everything you might imagine. Lots of music, lots of alcohol and lots of drugs. It was about 4:00 am one morning while I was riding around supplying food stands that I came across a Christian commune. They stood out not only because of the modesty of their cloths, but their singing and dancing. (They were also selling awesome coffee).
I spoke to them for a while and they told me they travelled from rock festival to rock festival and they tried to spread the message about Jesus. I asked them why they were doing that. From what I had seen over the past few days, Jesus was nowhere to be seen. One man from the group replied, "Yes, that is exactly why we are here".
I think perhaps Paul might have been beating himself up a bit by calling himself 'abnormal'. He was a sinner. The people in Woodstock were sinners. When Pope Francis was asked to describe himself, he replied, "I am a sinner". In the sense that Paul means it, I wonder if we are all 'abnormal'? And Christ can appear to all of us too!
Labels:
Paul,
Pope Francis,
Woodstock
Location:
West Sayville, NY, USA
The Purple Merchant
Yesterday I began the blog with: This Sunday's Gospel from John ends with the line, "And now I have told you this before it happens, so that when it happens you may believe". Jesus does not say 'if it happens', but instead, 'when it happens'. And the 'it' refers to Him being with us.
Sure enough, in Monday's 1st reading from Acts 16, we meet Lydia, who is a seller of purple cloths. Since purple dye was very rare, which therefore made purple cloth very expensive, we can assume Lydia might have had some wealth. No man is mentioned, so she might have been a widow. But she invites Paul et al into her home and the next thing we know, she is baptized. Why? Through Paul Lydia met Jesus. She believed! Just like Jesus said it would happen. When we know Jesus through others, we cannot help but want more. In Lydia's case, this meant baptism.
Kind of cool how we see this movement of Christian building right before our eyes.
Sure enough, in Monday's 1st reading from Acts 16, we meet Lydia, who is a seller of purple cloths. Since purple dye was very rare, which therefore made purple cloth very expensive, we can assume Lydia might have had some wealth. No man is mentioned, so she might have been a widow. But she invites Paul et al into her home and the next thing we know, she is baptized. Why? Through Paul Lydia met Jesus. She believed! Just like Jesus said it would happen. When we know Jesus through others, we cannot help but want more. In Lydia's case, this meant baptism.
Kind of cool how we see this movement of Christian building right before our eyes.
Labels:
Acts of the Apostles,
Lydia,
Paul
Location:
West Sayville, NY, USA
Saturday, April 30, 2016
Not 'If' but 'When'
This Sunday's Gospel from John ends with the line, "And now I have told you this before it happens, so that when it happens you may believe". Jesus does not say 'if it happens', but instead, 'when it happens'. And the 'it' refers to Him being with us.
I think a great example of this is the story of the Road to Emmaus. The travelers ask, “Were not our hearts burning within us while he talked with us on the road and opened the Scriptures to us?”. 'It' happened and they believed.
When does 'it' happen in our lives? All the time, but we probably lack the belief to see what it really is. Acts of kindness, acts of love, works of art, reconciliation of ourselves or of another, nature, etc. It is an endless list.
The next time we find our souls uplifted, our joy inexplicable or our hearts crushed by love, let us realize 'it' happened so we may believe.
I think a great example of this is the story of the Road to Emmaus. The travelers ask, “Were not our hearts burning within us while he talked with us on the road and opened the Scriptures to us?”. 'It' happened and they believed.
When does 'it' happen in our lives? All the time, but we probably lack the belief to see what it really is. Acts of kindness, acts of love, works of art, reconciliation of ourselves or of another, nature, etc. It is an endless list.
The next time we find our souls uplifted, our joy inexplicable or our hearts crushed by love, let us realize 'it' happened so we may believe.
Location:
West Sayville, NY, USA
Tuesday, April 26, 2016
All Are Welcome?
It is funny how Christians are fond of saying 'All are welcome'. It is a good idea for sure. Sometimes in living our lives though, 'all' becomes 'most' or even 'some'. Much is said about regular church goers who bristle when they come to Mass on Christmas, Easter or the standing room only Palm Sundays and 'their' seats are taken.
Well it is good to know we are not the first to question who can come to the table. In the 1st reading today, Luke takes up the question of if you have to be Jewish first to then become a Christian. It is easy to understand why that would be seen as the natural progression because Jesus was a devout Jew. Around the year 50 CE, the Council of Jerusalem took up the question. Paul argued that someone could go from being a Gentile to a Christian while Peter argued that for a Gentile to become a Christian, a Jewish conversion was a pre-requisite. Paul prevailed.
Historical but informative for us. I often use Pope Francis in this blog, but he invites everyone to the table. All are truly welcome. And we continue to try to accept everything that statement really means.
Location:
West Sayville, NY, USA
Monday, April 25, 2016
A change in tone
Since Easter, we have been listening to the 1st reading from Acts and the Gospel from John. Today though on the Feast of St. Mark the Evangelist, we have the 1st reading from St. Peter and the Gospel from Mark. It is cool how we see a reference to Mark from Peter in a bit of foreshadowing, then followed by the end of Mark's Gospel.
But it is the tone change today that struck me. We have been in John's last supper account and while beautiful, it is a bit heavy. Great theology that needs unpacking for sure. Today though, it is a succinct account that is typical of Mark. It is Jesus departing words to the remaining 11 at the Ascension. Scholars debate over the nature of the Resurrection and Jesus' appearance. All we know is that whatever happened, the experience so enlivened and animated His followers, that they spent their lives spreading the word.
Mark does not describe the reality of the Resurrection experience. It is beyond description. Rather, he just states the reality. And from that moment when the 11 are sent forth until now, that reality is what animates us all!
Location:
West Sayville, NY, USA
Thursday, April 21, 2016
Hamilton and Moses
So in the United States, the part of the government that controls the currency unveiled some new images that will be part of US paper money in the future. They had said they would change Alexander Hamilton with another image a while back. But, public outcry demanded that Hamilton remain on the $10 bill. Why this loyalty to a man, dead over 200 years and not even a president? Because of Broadway. The musical called Hamilton is the breakaway hit. Tickets are hard to come by and the waiting list to see the play is growing. The public is loving the story of this man, previously unknown to most. For many, the man on the $10 bill is now more real than he was just one year ago. He is a person, not just an image.
I was thinking about this as I read Act of the Apostles this morning. Paul is speaking and telling the story of Jewish history. From Moses, to Saul, to David and eventually to Jesus. For us the separation to Moses is approximately 3,300 years, but for Paul, it was about 1,200. Moreover, the Jewish tradition included midrash, which was a commentary on sacred scripture. Besides the scriptures themselves, discussion would happen all the time about the people, places and events that made up their faith.
What is the result? For Paul, the people of the Hebrew scriptures were real. Mythic to a certain extent, but also quite real. They could be appreciated and identified with. Not plaster statues but real people. Sometimes in Christianity, we think of the saints as perfect and unapproachable. Neither is true. They had flaws and showed their humanity. I am borrowing a line from my friend, Fr. Rob Ketcham, who said we cannot begin the process at perfection (for more on that, check out www.petersboat.com). For starting from perfection, it is only downhill.
Rather, let's know that Moses killed someone, Saul was paranoid, and David had some pretty big sins. When we see others as people and not perfection, we know that we too can work towards holiness.
I was thinking about this as I read Act of the Apostles this morning. Paul is speaking and telling the story of Jewish history. From Moses, to Saul, to David and eventually to Jesus. For us the separation to Moses is approximately 3,300 years, but for Paul, it was about 1,200. Moreover, the Jewish tradition included midrash, which was a commentary on sacred scripture. Besides the scriptures themselves, discussion would happen all the time about the people, places and events that made up their faith.
What is the result? For Paul, the people of the Hebrew scriptures were real. Mythic to a certain extent, but also quite real. They could be appreciated and identified with. Not plaster statues but real people. Sometimes in Christianity, we think of the saints as perfect and unapproachable. Neither is true. They had flaws and showed their humanity. I am borrowing a line from my friend, Fr. Rob Ketcham, who said we cannot begin the process at perfection (for more on that, check out www.petersboat.com). For starting from perfection, it is only downhill.
Rather, let's know that Moses killed someone, Saul was paranoid, and David had some pretty big sins. When we see others as people and not perfection, we know that we too can work towards holiness.
Location:
West Sayville, NY, USA
Sunday, April 17, 2016
Certitude and Order, Certitude and Order, Certitude and Order
In today's first reading from Act of the Apostles, we find Paul and Barnabas rejected from the Jewish synagogue and welcomed by the Gentiles. The lens of 2000 years of history can lead us to judge those Jewish people harshly. For they clearly rejected Jesus, (I say 'those Jewish people' because I referring to those in the story today only. Jesus and the early church has many Jewish followers). For those who rejected Paul and Barnabas, what where they rejecting? A complicated answer is needed for sure, but part of it is that Jesus threatened the Jewish law. He asks Jews to think of the big picture and not be slaves to the law. This eventually got Jesus killed. But those Jews were not bad people. They were following the law and the law gave them a way to think about God and life that made sense. People and events fit into nice and neat categories they could understand. They had certitude and they had order.
It is vitally important to know that need for certitude and order still goes on today among Christians. Just this week I read part of an essay from a conservative Catholic very worried about Pope Francis Exhortation last week on the family. (Here is the article: http://theweek.com/articles/617870/retrograde-intransigence-conservative-catholics). This author was nervous about the lack of order as he saw it in Pope Francis. I would be sure this comes from his love of the Church and his not wanting anything bad to happen to it. A noble concern for sure.
One of the recurrent themes here is just what the Jewish people we find in the reading today feared; the lack of certitude and the lack of order. When things don't fit into categories and when life gets messy, we sometimes put up a wall and say the 'other' is the problem. For many of us our lived experience tells us that life is mostly lived in the grey, smack dab between the black and the white. And for sure, it is where Jesus lived his life. He had clear instructions to us on how to live, but he knew that to know humanity, he could not remain on the lofty perch.
It is important not to judge the Jewish people back in the day with scorn, as we ourselves often do the same thing.
Please feel free to continue the discussion by clicking on comments. We can all stand to learn from each other. I would especially love to hear the thoughts of our Polish, German and Irish friends following this blog.
Have a great week.
It is vitally important to know that need for certitude and order still goes on today among Christians. Just this week I read part of an essay from a conservative Catholic very worried about Pope Francis Exhortation last week on the family. (Here is the article: http://theweek.com/articles/617870/retrograde-intransigence-conservative-catholics). This author was nervous about the lack of order as he saw it in Pope Francis. I would be sure this comes from his love of the Church and his not wanting anything bad to happen to it. A noble concern for sure.
One of the recurrent themes here is just what the Jewish people we find in the reading today feared; the lack of certitude and the lack of order. When things don't fit into categories and when life gets messy, we sometimes put up a wall and say the 'other' is the problem. For many of us our lived experience tells us that life is mostly lived in the grey, smack dab between the black and the white. And for sure, it is where Jesus lived his life. He had clear instructions to us on how to live, but he knew that to know humanity, he could not remain on the lofty perch.
It is important not to judge the Jewish people back in the day with scorn, as we ourselves often do the same thing.
Please feel free to continue the discussion by clicking on comments. We can all stand to learn from each other. I would especially love to hear the thoughts of our Polish, German and Irish friends following this blog.
Have a great week.
Saturday, April 16, 2016
Not much changes after all
In today's Gospel from John, we see followers leaving Jesus. It is not implied. John actually says they left him and returned to their former life. This was Jesus they left!
Sometimes people who go to church can be critical of people who do not or maybe did at one point but no longer go. They walk away for many reasons, but ultimately it is because of what the disciples say in this Gospel passage, "This is saying is hard. Who can accept it?". It would be interesting to know how many of those who walked away from Jesus came back? How many come back now?
The doors then, and the doors now, are always open. This week in the readings, we saw Paul, who tried hard to keep the doors closed, welcomed in. We saw Pope Francis' Exhortation this week opening the door. How cool it is that not much changes after all? Thank God!
Labels:
Jesus,
Paul,
Pope Francis
Location:
Commack, NY, USA
Thursday, April 14, 2016
Sign me up now!
Today's reading from Acts has the seemingly random story of Phillip and the Ethiopian Eunuch. Actually it is so random it is probably literal. A eunuch at the time, although in the Queen's court, would have been excluded from formal worship. Very much seen as a sexual minority. This would certainly be in line with the author of Acts, Luke. In Luke's Gospel, we see women, the poor and the sick as subjects of God's mercy and love.
Today though, Phillip finds the eunuch reading from Isaiah. Phillip asks him if he knows what he is reading and the eunuch asks Phillip to teach him. So transformed by Phillip's telling of the saving power of Jesus, the eunuch sees some water, stops the caravan and asks to be baptized. And he was. No doubt, he heard the joy and enthusiasm of Phillip and he wanted some of that.
Today, it seems where ever Pope Francis goes, people see the joy and peace of his life and want their lives to be the same. This is no doubt what the eunuch felt. "Sign me up now, I want some of that!"
Who does God call? All of us, even the Eunuch in the Queen's court.
Today though, Phillip finds the eunuch reading from Isaiah. Phillip asks him if he knows what he is reading and the eunuch asks Phillip to teach him. So transformed by Phillip's telling of the saving power of Jesus, the eunuch sees some water, stops the caravan and asks to be baptized. And he was. No doubt, he heard the joy and enthusiasm of Phillip and he wanted some of that.
Today, it seems where ever Pope Francis goes, people see the joy and peace of his life and want their lives to be the same. This is no doubt what the eunuch felt. "Sign me up now, I want some of that!"
Who does God call? All of us, even the Eunuch in the Queen's court.
Labels:
Acts of the Apostles,
eunuch,
Phillip
Location:
West Islip, NY, USA
Wednesday, April 13, 2016
A Different Response
The story being told to us in the Acts of the Apostles has turned dark in the past few days. Remember that right after Easter, we find the newly energized disciples entering the world again with courage and conviction. They were followed themselves (the word 'disciple' means 'to follow'). They were healing others and sharing all they had.
But this week, the storm clouds have gathered and things turn ugly. The establishment is threatened by the 'good news' they are hearing. Bad words turn to bad actions and Stephan is stoned to death.
Remember a few things though.
First, what the Jews were doing was permissible by law. Just like today, we see life being legally exterminated in this country.
Second, this is the cost of true discipleship. It is great to be a Christian when things are going well, but when the bottom drops out, it is not so much fun.
Lastly, the Acts of the Apostles are not the only readings the Church gives us. We have John's Gospel as well, reminding us the Jesus truly is God. And the response John gives us is so different than the world would have us believe is correct. After Stephan is killed, today's response would be to fight back and look for revenge. It is almost a knee-jerk reaction. But the Church holds out to us a totally different way to think about it. John reminds us that Jesus loves us unconditionally. Jesus does not take evil out of the world. He gives us a way to deal with it. So as we read about the bad that happens to the courageous followers of Jesus, we know that revenge is not the helpful and that the 'bad stuff' is not the end of the story.
Sunday, April 10, 2016
How could they (and we) miss it?
Two
quick thoughts on today’s Gospel.
First, we find the Disciples fishing. A very normal activity but this was not a
normal time. They had just witnessed the
Resurrected Jesus. An event that had
never happened before or since. So why
where they going back to their day to day lives? Could they have been sharing the same reality
we do? When we go to Communion, we are
experiencing the same Risen Jesus they did.
Last night I went to Mass and today I will be working in my yard and
back to work tomorrow. The point is not
to judge the disciples as missing the point.
Rather, don’t we do the same thing?
Second, when Jesus was on the shore, the disciples did not
recognize Him. Again, we might say
how? They had been with Him for years
and He had already appeared to them since Easter. So here we must also ask could this be the
same reality for us? Pope Francis has
been showing us Christ in the poor and disenfranchised. I get pumped up with that, but I suspect I am
not living that dynamic in my own life.
When I was studying for my Masters at the Seminary, I was leaving one
evening with a classmate and we were talking about the Gospel passage where
Jesus tells us to love our neighbor. My
friend said he was fine with that until it meant the annoying guy that sat in
the next office. So the ‘idea’ of the
Gospel is great. For sure its gets messy
in our lived experience. So maybe the
disciple’s lack of recognition of Jesus is something we can all relate to.
Labels:
disciples,
gospel,
Resurrection
Location:
West Sayville, NY, USA
Saturday, April 2, 2016
Peter's Amazing Journey and Thinking Outside the Box
I found this week’s 1st readings, all from Act of the Apostles interesting for two different reasons.
I found this week’s 1st readings, all from Act of the Apostles interesting for two different reasons.
First, Peter and John cure a man on their way to the
Temple. What must have that been like
for Peter? Just last week he was denying
Jesus in a very public way. Now, he has
the power to cure. Luke does not really
explore what was in Peter’s head. The
point of the story was the power given to the remaining 11 due to Jesus’
resurrection. But I still wonder what
Peter was thinking. I may assume some
humility and sense of not being worthy.
When Pope Francis was asked to describe himself, the first adjective he offered
was ‘sinner’. Those truly called by God
are always wondering why God called them.
(Remember Moses arguing with God because he could not figure out how a
man with a speech impediment could lead people?). Makes you wonder how about those religious leaders
that tell you they are the ‘special’ ones called by God. Most of the time they are easy to see through.
The other interesting thing I found in these readings is the
reaction of the healing. It is similar
to what we saw in one of John’s gospels a few weeks ago. After the healing, all the religious leaders
scramble around and argue if this healing was valid. You see, they could not make sense of it and
it did not fit into any category they knew.
And if it did not fit into a paradigm they understood, it was
wrong. We are used to Jesus breaking all
the rules during his time. We root for
him as he takes the side of the underdog, especially in Luke. It is a good
lesson the next time we see something in our lives that pulls us to stretch our
understanding of the world to a place we don’t normally go. It would be awesome to have the faith of the
living Christ that the apostles had so that we may look beyond categories with
the confidence of Peter and John.
Monday, March 14, 2016
An Argument at the Last Supper
This Palm Sunday we again read the Passion of Jesus. We hear this every year on Palm Sunday from either Matthew, Mark or Luke. On Good Friday we hear it from John. I think if we are not careful, the words become like nice background noise. Pleasant but not revealing. At least that happens to me.
I was struck in pre-reading Sunday's Passion by the line Luke includes, "Then an argument broke out among them which of them should be regarded as the greatest." Think about this from Jesus' perspective. The writing is on the wall and he knows his ministry and his life are going to end. He has to be holding his emotions in check. Probably scared and maybe disheartened that all his work is coming to an end. So he gathers all his closest friends together to celebrate the Passover meal. This was (and is) a magnificent Jewish tradition. It is kind of a big deal. And in the meal, he gives us the Eucharist. Think about that for a minute. The Jesus we are given in Church every week is the same Jesus at the Last Supper. Not 'like' the Jesus from the Last Supper, but the exact same Jesus. So, with great solemnness and gravity, he conducts this whole night. And when it is over, perhaps there was a sense of satisfaction. Maybe optimism. Maybe this whole thing is going to work out after all.
But as soon as he is done, what does he hear? His followers arguing about who is the greatest. He had to be thinking, "Really, this is what you got out of tonight?". This is like when we have small children and we buy them a really nice gift but they find playing with the box a better option. What were these guys thinking?
Perhaps they had the right intention but the wrong question. Maybe they really did get things were coming to an end. And maybe they just wanted to make it so Jesus' work would carry on. They needed to know how best to do that and just addressed the question in an awkward manner. If I am trying my best to follow Jesus, sometimes it is hard to know how much of me should be involved and how much of Jesus should be involved. And where does one start and one end.
Does anyone have a thought on how to interpret the 'Argument'?
I was struck in pre-reading Sunday's Passion by the line Luke includes, "Then an argument broke out among them which of them should be regarded as the greatest." Think about this from Jesus' perspective. The writing is on the wall and he knows his ministry and his life are going to end. He has to be holding his emotions in check. Probably scared and maybe disheartened that all his work is coming to an end. So he gathers all his closest friends together to celebrate the Passover meal. This was (and is) a magnificent Jewish tradition. It is kind of a big deal. And in the meal, he gives us the Eucharist. Think about that for a minute. The Jesus we are given in Church every week is the same Jesus at the Last Supper. Not 'like' the Jesus from the Last Supper, but the exact same Jesus. So, with great solemnness and gravity, he conducts this whole night. And when it is over, perhaps there was a sense of satisfaction. Maybe optimism. Maybe this whole thing is going to work out after all.
But as soon as he is done, what does he hear? His followers arguing about who is the greatest. He had to be thinking, "Really, this is what you got out of tonight?". This is like when we have small children and we buy them a really nice gift but they find playing with the box a better option. What were these guys thinking?
Perhaps they had the right intention but the wrong question. Maybe they really did get things were coming to an end. And maybe they just wanted to make it so Jesus' work would carry on. They needed to know how best to do that and just addressed the question in an awkward manner. If I am trying my best to follow Jesus, sometimes it is hard to know how much of me should be involved and how much of Jesus should be involved. And where does one start and one end.
Does anyone have a thought on how to interpret the 'Argument'?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)